Friday, June 22, 2007
Judge Bans the Word "Rape" in His Courtroom
"Last month, Lancaster County District Judge Jeffre Cheuvront denied a motion by prosecutors that would have prohibited Safi’s attorneys from using words like “sex” and “intercourse” when describing the encounter between Safi and Bowen.
The Lancaster County Attorney’s Office had argued the words would imply Bowen consented to have sex.
Cheuvront also has sustained an earlier motion by defense attorneys barring the words “rape” and “sexual assault kit.”
In Bowen’s opinion, Cheuvront’s ruling means she will have to lie on the witness stand.
“The word ‘sex’ implies consent,” she said. “I never once would describe (what happened) as sex. He’s making me commit perjury.”
Clarence Mock, one of Safi’s attorneys, said Cheuvront made the rulings to keep the trial fair.
The word “rape,” is not a legal term, he said. “Sexual assault” is, but whether a defendant committed that crime is a question for a jury to answer based on evidence at trial, Mock said.
“Under the rules of evidence, witnesses can’t reach legal conclusions,” he said." (source)
The Man had a good point, let' put this judge in prison for a week and see what words he uses to describe what happens to him there...